We currenty have two cookies: our Signature Cookie is a brown butter, oatmeal, chocolate chip, topped with flakey sea salt. We also have a seasonal Rice Krispie Cookie made with brown butter and toasted marshmallows.
No. But I do care strongly about ingredient quality and I use as many local and organic ingredients as possible. I don't go to the store and buy whatever is the cheapest. I'm very picky about what I use and I won't swap ingredients/brands. I will prob make a vegan cookie eventually.
Signature Cookie: unsalted butter, semi-sweet chocolate chips, dark brown sugar, rolled oats, flour, eggs, unsweetened coconut, cane sugar, brown coconut sugar, oat milk, vanilla extract, baking soda, sea saltRice Krispie Cookie: unsalted butter (pasteurized cream, lactic acid), dark brown sugar (sugar, cane syrups, caramel coloring), eggs, flour (unbleached hard red wheat flour, enzyme or malted barley flour), granulated coconut blossom nectar, organic brown rice crisp cereal (organic whole grain brown rice, organic cane sugar, sea salt), malted milk powder (malted barley, wheat, milk, hydrolyzed wheat gluten,baking soda, salt), marshmallow (corn syrup, cane sugar, modified cornstarch, gelatin, water, natural flavors, tetrasodium pyrophosphate), vanilla bean paste (cane sugar, water, vanilla extract, vanilla bean seeds, gum tragacanth), sea salt, baking powder (corn starch, monocalcium phosphate, baking soda), baking soda
Message me on Instagram @cookieboycle or email email@example.comYou can also find my cookies at Ready Set! Coffee on Detroit Ave.
I will deliver for free to Ohio City and Tremont. I will also deliver within a 5-mile radius of Tremont (like Lakewood, Old Brooklyn, etc). These deliveries must pay a $5 delivery fee. I will deliver up to 10 miles for a $10 delivery fee. Anyone is welcome to pick-up for free in Tremont.
No. But if you're further than 10 miles away from Tremont, you must pick-up. Tremont and Ohio City deliveries are free.
Individual Signature Cookies are $4.00. Packs of three come in a custom milk carton and are $12.00. A dozen cookies come individually wrapped in a pastry box and cost $42.00
Each cookie weighs between 2.85 and 3 ounces.
You can pay me through Venmo @cookieboycle or I can send you a Square link to pay with a card. If you pay with a card, there is a small processing fee. Payment must be received before your pick-up or delivery.I'll also accept cash and Zelle!
You should eat or freeze them within 3 days of buying.
I bake with high-quality local and organic ingredients. My cookies are baked at home in small batches.
Legend has it that when Lake Erie caught fire in 1969, something magical happened beneath the surface. It was said that heat and turmoil fused together the essence of a young boy and batch of freshly baked cookies, giving rise to Cookie Boy.
Soon thereafter, young children would catch glimpses of a half-cookie-half-boy creature roaming the streets, blending into the shadows. His presence was often dismissed as nothing more than folklore or childish tales. However, with each passing day, the scent of freshly baked cookies grew stronger throughout Cleveland. Adults remained oblivious, but the children reveled in its embrace. They would gather together in secret, sharing stories of Cookie Boy’s exploits and his delightful confections.
It has been said that Cookie Boy would sneak into the homes of local patrons under the cloak of night, carefully using their ovens to bake batches of his irresistible cookies, which were said to possess an extraordinary power. When people tasted them, their worries melted away, replaced by a sense of warmth and happiness.
The story of Cookie Boy has endured across many decades, passed down from one generation to the next. Sightings of Cookie Boy steadily declined from the 1980s onward. Until early 2023…the scent of cookies began to spread over Cleveland once again. Cookie Boy has returned.